U.S. Capital

Florida May Limit Access to Medical Malpractice Records

May 22, 2018

Tampa, FL (Law Firm Newswire) May 22, 2018 – In 2004, Florida voters approved Amendment 7, giving patients access to all records of medical-care providers’ known as “adverse medical-incident reports.” Recently, however, some have voiced concern surrounding the implementation of the amendment.

As former general counsel to Governor Rick Scott and member of the state Constitution Revision Commission, Tim Cerio feels that even though the 2004 vote found the public in heavy agreement, change is necessary. Cerio, who is currently working alongside the politically-active GrayRobinson law firm, has filed a proposal to alter Amendment 7 to create limits on the records that lawyers have access to for claims against hospitals, doctors and other medical providers.

This proposal would take adverse medical-incident reports and exclude from them the documents that are “protected by federal laws or regulations relating to patient safety quality improvement,” says Cerio. Any access to these reports would not “abrogate attorney-client communications or work product privileges for patients, health care providers, or health care facilities,” he adds.

Cerio claims that his wish is not to overturn the public’s ability to access to these records and that he wants to change the proposal to only slightly limit the accessibility. The adverse medical-incident reports are key to many medical malpractice claims, and any truncation of access would hinder victims’ ability to make cases against doctors who have multiple claims of malpractice against them.

The proposal is based on Cerio’s belief that the original objective of Amendment 7 has been overlooked. With a broadened approach to Amendment 7 that, according to Cerio, was not the initial intention, hospitals are having a difficult time preparing for legal disputes. He says, “There has been a stream of cases that have expanded the impact of Amendment 7 and created an ability for litigants to get information that was not intended. Attorney-client work product is sacrosanct, and for the courts to expand that, I think, is not a good reading of the original intent of Amendment 7.”

There are two extremely conflicting sides to the argument. While case studies express that a hospital withholding documents could allow the defendant to escape seemingly unjustly unscathed, lobbyist Jan Gorrie believes that patient safety should be held as the first priority. Gorrie, who represents hospitals, says, “If your institution didn’t do something right, you want them to take a serious self-examination, which to some degree won’t happen if they don’t have these processes protected.”

The issue is potentially reemerging in the November 2018 ballot for the public to decide what is best for both plaintiffs and defendants of medical malpractice cases. On one side there are the insurance companies and healthcare providers, while on the other there are trial attorneys who want as much access as possible to the victims’ information.

Robert Joyce, a Tampa medical malpractice attorney with the law firm of Joyce & Reyes, said, “Patients have a right to know what they are dealing with. Plaintiffs and their attorneys deserve to have the knowledge necessary to bring a case to justice.”

Learn more at http://www.joyceandreyespa.com

Joyce and Reyes Law Firm, P.A.
307 S Hyde Park Ave
Tampa, FL 33606
Call: 813.251.2007

View Larger Map

  • Abuse in Florida nursing homes is apparent with hidden cameras
    Following the 13 deaths at a Hollywood Hills nursing home during Hurricane Irma, many families are concerned for the safety of their loved ones in the care of nursing facilities. As a result, more families are placing hidden cameras inside the nursing home rooms to see what is actually happening to elderly patients. Recently, disturbing […]
  • FHP trooper hit by drunk driver while investigating previous accident
    Late last year, a Florida Highway Patrol trooper, Daniel Cruz, was investigating an earlier accident scene when he was hit by a drunk driver. At around 1 a.m. on Okeechobee Road, John Bencosme, 26, of Miami, was driving his Hyundai Velastar while intoxicated. He crashed into the cars from the previous accident, which made a […]
  • In Florida medical malpractice lawsuits rarely lead to disclipline
    Medical malpractice cases in Florida have consistently been seen as an issue, but the state health officals rarely take any action against doctors. Under the law, doctors must report all malpractice lawsuits even when closed. However, little action is being taken towards getting these dangerous doctors out of practice. Florida lawmakers have called this situation […]
  • Florida Supreme Court eliminates parts of 2013 medical malpractice law
    On November 9, the Florida Supreme Court found itself disunited. The court rejected multiple aspects of a 2013 medical-malpractice law because the changes “have gashed Florida’s constitutional right to privacy.” Pieces of the 2013 law, justices said, could potentially allow for patients’ medical information to be disclosed even if it does not relate to the […]
  • Florida local sues Whitehall nursing home for negligence
    A nursing home neglect lawsuit has been filed against a Florida facility, with the plaintiff claiming his care was so poor that he needed additional surgery and medication. Ross Bayer, 66, was in a landscaping accident over seven months ago that resulted in breaking both of his feet. He was instructed to go through two […]