U.S. Capital

Texas Supreme Court Hears Arguments in Dispute Over Deed Granting Oil and Gas Interests

May 12, 2017

Austin Oil and Gas Attorney, Gregory D. Jordan

Austin Oil and Gas Attorney, Gregory D. Jordan

Austin, TX (Law Firm Newswire) May 12, 2017 – The Texas Supreme Court considered competing arguments over a property deed that granted oil and gas interests and gave rise to opposing royalty claims.

The case involves a 55-acre tract that was purchased by the Wenske family, with the previous owners retaining a one-quarter non-participating royalty interest (NPRI). The property was subsequently purchased by the Ealy family, with the Wenskes reserving three-eighths of the minerals. The Wenskes say the Ealys are solely responsible for the cost of the NPRI, but the lower court sided with the Ealys, holding that each of the mineral owners bears its proportionate share of the burden of the NPRI.

“Disputes over royalty interests are quite common,” said Gregory D. Jordan, an Austin oil and gas attorney with the Law Offices of Gregory D. Jordan who has handled many such claims. “Which party bears the burden of a royalty interest usually depends on the language of the relevant deeds. In order to avoid unexpected consequences, parties should consult competent counsel when conveying oil and gas interests,” continues Jordan.

The state high court’s decision may rest on whether its holding in the 1969 case of Bass v. Harper is still good law. In that case, the Texas Supreme Court held that a deed conveyed a royalty interest that was burdened by multiple prior royalty reservations, leaving the property buyer with a fractional interest. The Wenskes argued that their case is directly analogous, but the Ealys argued that the deed language in the present case is different from that in Bass, and the holding in Bass is no longer good law.

The Wenskes argued that the Bass case is controlling, and the plain language of the deed shows that the Ealys are taking the property subject to the burden of the NPRI, and the Wenskes are reserving a royalty interest free of that burden.

To learn more, visit http://www.theaustintriallawyer.com/

Law Offices of Gregory D. Jordan
5608 Parkcrest Drive, Suite 310
Austin, Texas 78731
Call: 512-419-0684

View Larger Map

  • Texas appeals court’s decision shows importance of wording in noncompete agreements
    A recent decision by a Texas appeals court demonstrates that the wording of a noncompete agreement must be precise. In the case, East Texas Copy Systems, Inc. v. Player, the Court of Appeals in Texarkana ruled that a noncompete agreement was nonbinding due to the language used in the agreement. As part of the sale […]
  • Texas property owners file class-action suit against Devon Energy over royalties
    A class-action lawsuit has been filed by Texas property owners alleging that Devon Energy used sham transactions to underpay natural gas royalties. On January 6, class-action status was granted by U.S. District Judge Ed Kinkeade in Dallas, allowing the four individuals who brought the lawsuit to represent the interests of thousands of landowners. The judge […]
  • Investment firms sue oil company, alleging breach of contract
    An oil company was sued by two investment firms in Harris County District Court in Texas over an alleged breach of contract. SSG Advisors, LLC and Chiron Financial LLC filed the lawsuit against Daybreak Oil and Gas Inc., claiming that Daybreak violated an agreement among the three companies. The investment firms claim they are owed […]