U.S. Capital

Florida Supreme Court Rules Hospital Must Provide Records in Medical Malpractice Case

Feb 27, 2017

Tampa, FL (Law Firm Newswire) February 27, 2017 – The Florida Supreme Court issued an important ruling in a medical malpractice case, deciding that a 2004 constitutional amendment requires a hospital to provide medical records to a patient’s family.

The family of Marie Charles had filed the lawsuit against Southern Baptist Hospital of Florida, Inc., doing business as Baptist Medical Center, alleging that negligence on the part of the medical provider caused her to suffer a serious neurological injury. The hospital system had argued that it should not have to turn over all documents, because the 2004 federal law provides confidentiality to hospitals that voluntarily submit information about medical errors. The state Supreme Court held that the federal law does not preempt state requirements on the disclosure of medical information.

“This is an important ruling for patients,” said Robert Joyce, a Tampa medical malpractice attorney with Joyce & Reyes. “When patients are injured by medical mistakes, they must have access to their records in order to obtain fair compensation for the harm they have suffered.”

In a 5-2 decision, the state Supreme Court overturned the 1st District Court of Appeal’s ruling that the Jacksonville hospital was shielded by a patient-safety law from being required to turn over documents in the medical malpractice case. The ruling concerned Amendment 7, a ballot initiative approved by voters, with the purpose of expanding patients’ access to medical records.

The majority opinion by Justice Barbara Pariente stated that Congress intended the federal patient safety act to improve health care, not shield providers from their responsibilities under Amendment 7. The opinion was joined by Chief Justice Jorge Labarga, justices Peggy Quince and R. Fred Lewis and Senior Justice James E.C. Perry.

The parties had filed a stipulation of dismissal the day before oral arguments, but the Court rejected it, stating that it could not let the 1st District holding stand, since it held that part of the state constitution was invalid.

Learn more at http://www.joyceandreyespa.com

Joyce and Reyes Law Firm, P.A.
307 S Hyde Park Ave
Tampa, FL 33606
Call: 813.251.2007

View Larger Map

  • More Florida car accidents caused by road debris
    An analysis of Florida crash data shows that car accidents caused by road debris are on the rise. Car accidents have resulted from drivers hitting objects in the road or swerving to avoid them. In some cases, cars have been hit by debris from trucks with unsecured loads. In 1998, a 13-year-old girl survived a […]
  • Physicians’ group asks Florida Supreme Court to reconsider medical malpractice case
    A doctors’ group has requested that the Florida Supreme Court reconsider its rejection of an arbitration agreement in a lawsuit involving medical malpractice. The request was filed by attorneys for physician Eileen Hernandez and Women’s Care Florida LLC, approximately two weeks after the arbitration agreement was tossed out in a case involving a stillborn baby. […]
  • Florida ranked as most dangerous state for car accidents involving pedestrians
    Florida is the most dangerous state in the country for pedestrians. According to the advocacy group Smart Growth America, Florida had 5,142 pedestrian fatalities from 2005 to 2014 and a pedestrian death rate of 2.66 per 100,000 people. The group assigned Florida a high Pedestrian Danger Index of 177 by comparing data on pedestrian deaths […]
  • Florida wrongful death lawsuit settled for $1.7 million
    The parents of a young mentally ill man who was shot and killed by a sheriff’s deputy in Florida have settled their wrongful death lawsuit for $1.7 million. Michael Camberdella was shot and killed by a Palm Beach County sheriff’s deputy in Boynton Beach, Florida in 2012. According to the family’s attorney, Michael, age 18, […]
  • Multi-million dollar jury award in Florida brain injury lawsuit
    A jury awarded $18 million to a Florida man who suffered a traumatic brain injury in a bar fight. Joshua Mathews suffered brain injuries after a 2012 altercation at Pete’s Bar in Neptune Beach, Florida. Mathews fell and hit his head on the cement after being punched in the face. He filed a lawsuit against […]