Would a Scarlet Car Tag for Repeat Drunk Driving Offenders Work?

Austin, TX (Law Firm Newswire) March 1, 2016 – Mississippi wants their proposed Scarlet Letter Tag bill to ride herd on repeat drunk driving offenders. A second-time DUI offender would be issued a yellow license plate and scarlet red tags, and have to live with the shame of being publicly labelled for one year.

Despite research done in other states with laws similar to the proposed Scarlet Letter Tag bill that show such punishment does not significantly reduce DUI deaths, Mississippi may push the bill through to gauge the number of repeat offenders on the road.

Lawmaker Gary Chism indicated his reasoning behind the proposed bill, saying: “If you [haven’t] learned your lesson after the first one, then we need to step in and do something to get your attention . . . Maybe if all your neighbors know, and the Highway Patrol know, they won’t be as likely to get out there weaving on the roads again.”

As the debate rages on, those in favor of the humiliation of yellow plates with red tags suggest that everyone knows the law with regard to not drinking and driving, but they choose to ignore and should be held accountable in some fashion. Perhaps a colourful wakeup call is appropriate.

Those who think humiliation is not the route to follow, such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), say the second-time offender plates and tags are over-criminalization and may cause offenders to lose their jobs.

“No one has yet to address the one question that seems to be at the core of this issue, and that is: if you are on your second drunk driving offense there is a good likelihood you are a problem drinker. Conventional legal ramifications have obviously not stopped the offender and yellow plates with red tags likely won’t stop a determined drinker. So, what’s the solution?” said Austin plaintiff’s DWI attorney, Bobby Lee of Lee, Gober & Reyna. That is the conundrum inherent in dealing with repeat drunk driving offenders.

Would such a law work in Texas? “I have my doubts it would, because the problem remains the same here as it does in any other state with a drunk driving issue. If people want to drink and not stop in spite of all the laws out there, they are going to keep doing it. Drinking and driving is a human problem,” Lee said.

To learn more, visit http://www.lgrlawfirm.com

Lee, Gober & Reyna
11940 Jollyville Road #220-S
Austin, Texas 78759
Phone: 512.478.8080

  • Even cyclists need to be on the lookout for distracted drivers
    It’s bad enough that drivers and pedestrians have to be on the alert for distracted drivers, but not many people think about cyclists. Cyclists are a large part of the driving landscape in many American cities, and if a driver is texting while behind the wheel, the cyclist is at risk of being hit. Houston, one of America’s largest cities, still lets drivers text while traveling on freeways, although that may change. The main argument against passing any legislation that restricts a driver’s right to use cell phones while they are driving involves the freedom to communicate and government interference […]
  • Texas amps up motorcycle awareness education
    Texas is famous for many things, including leading most other states for the number of drunk driving deaths on their highways. Additionally, it has an extremely large number of motorcycles registered and a very high number of biker deaths. Consider yet another deadly crash on Highway 69. A biker was heading north, lost control of his motorcycle and hit a guardrail. The highway was shut down for a number of hours while accident scene personnel worked to assess the crash and clear away the debris. It is not just the fact that motorcyclists are not protected like passengers in a […]
  • Semi truck hits two changing a tire
    The two people killed in this case did not stand a chance. An 18-wheeler hit their vehicle on I-10 near Vinton. The victims were changing a tire under the Vernon overpass when the truck, driven by 61-year-old Patrick O’Leary, ran into them. The trucker was arrested and booked into the county jail. His bail was set at $400,000. In this instance, it was not made clear just why the trucker did run into the vehicle under the underpass and the police indicated they would be investigating further to determine what happened. There are any one of a number of things […]
  • Texarkana popular bar sued in wrongful death action that left two dead, one permanently disabled
    It was 2013 when this ugly accident happened. The bar, Hopkins Icehouse, its owners and the defendant, Chad Caldwell, are being sued for the deaths of Tameka Pavon and Jercarlos Hawkins. Caldwell ran a red light on Sept. 29, 2013 and slammed into the vehicle carrying Pavon, Hawkins and a third individual, Genaro Camacho, who sustained a severe traumatic brain injury, from which he is not expected to totally recover. At the time of the crash, Caldwell was charged by police for one count of intoxication assault and two counts of intoxication manslaughter. He landed in jail and is currently […]
  • Ethan Couch apprehended in Mexico
    The Couch case is an immediate flashpoint for numerous people who feel justice was not served in his case. The now 18-year-old Ethan Couch, a.k.a. the Affluenza kid, received a light sentence for killing four in a drunk-driving collision in 2013. His attorney argued successfully that he was so spoiled and rich that he did not know right from wrong. Recently, Couch was featured in a video that showed him drinking and playing beer pong, clearly in violation of the conditions of his parole. The video found its way to the police. Additionally, Couch failed to arrive for a parole […]