California Supreme Court Defines Legal Separation for Divorcing Couples

Orange County, CA (Law Firm Newswire) September 18, 2015 – The California Supreme Court on July 20 ruled that it is necessary for divorcing couples to live in different residences in order to claim separate property and qualify as legally separated.

Under California family law, the income and property each spouse acquires during a marriage is considered community property to be divided between them during a divorce. However, couples often separate years before they divorce, removing all their earnings from consideration after separation when determining community property. When the couple separates, each spouse gets to keep whatever they accumulate.

According to the Supreme Court guidelines, a couple that continues to reside in the same house cannot qualify as separated when dividing assets. The ruling reinforces a bright-line rule, which makes the establishment of individual residences the minimum requirement to legally define when a couple is separated and income and property are no longer shared.

California divorce mediator Gerald A. Maggio said, “The ruling provides clarity to everyone involved in the divorce proceedings, so that there is no confusion or disagreement as to when a couple actually separates. The Supreme Court has prioritized living arrangements when deciding separation over other factors such as separate bank accounts or the care of children.”

The court made its ruling in the Alameda County Superior Court case of divorcing couple Keith and Sheryl Davis. According to court documents, Sheryl Davis claimed they formally separated in 2006 when she declared the marriage was over. She said they began living as roommates in different bedrooms under the same roof for the sake of their children and had taken steps to separate their finances. Keith Davis contended that the separation began in July 2011, when she moved out of their Castro Valley, California, home.

Sheryl Davis argued that Keith Davis was not entitled to a share of her earnings as the couple’s arrangement met the requirement of living separately during those five years, when she earned more than he did. However, the state Supreme Court ruled that her income until July 2011 was community property, of which Keith Davis is now eligible to receive a share.

“Although the Supreme Court ruling serves to avoid ambiguity, it does not take into account aspects such as the parenting responsibilities between an estranged couple, as well as financial considerations,” said Maggio. “One spouse may have to move out of the marital residence and find a new home as a prerequisite to establishing the date of separation, which could pose financial difficulties. Mediation can be helpful in cases that involve children and for resolving the many issues that arise from separation.”

Learn more at http://www.cadivorcemediators.com/

California Divorce Mediators
Main Office
420 Exchange
Suite 270-B
Irvine, CA 92602
Call: (949) 553-0911

Riverside Office
3750 University Avenue, Suite 670
Riverside, CA 92501
Call: (949) 553-0911

  • Middle Class Incomes and Divorce Mediation
    A common theory that has been doing the rounds for many years is that the American justice system is made for the wealthy. This despite not being entirely true does have some elements of truth about it. The American judicial system in unique and for couples going through a divorce it can be complex to […]
  • The Judge Has Much Much Less Time For You Than Your Divorce Mediator
    A common phrase used by couples going through a divorce is to get “justice and what they are legally entitled to.” Often times, couples, wives and husbands who have had bitterness in the ending of the marriage look at the courts as their only savior.  These couples look at Orange County divorce mediation as a […]
  • 5 Things To Avoid In Divorce Mediation
    Orange County divorce mediation can be termed as being the pinnacle of the divorce process. This is because it can be said to hold the key to how life after divorce will look like. If you are not careful in your divorce mediation decisions, you might as well end up having a long, drawn out […]
  • Is Venting Counter-Productive In Divorce Mediation?
    What is it that you do when you are upset or things are going against you? You simply vent, most people vent out their emotions and anger when they feel let down or hurt. Orange County divorce on the other hand is where people get emotionally hurt and traumatized at the prospect of ending their […]
  • Frequently Asked Questions about Divorce Mediation
    While it is true that the reach of Orange County divorce mediation continues to increase with time, it is also true that some doubts and questions remain in the minds of the people regarding the process. Orange County divorce mediation is simply put a process where the two spouses are made to sit and talk […]
  • Tips on Mediation with Conflict Personalities–Part 2
    This blog is a continuation of the previous blog titled “Tips to Mediation with Conflict Personalities–Part 1”. This blog series highlights the tips that a spouse can take when going into Orange County divorce mediation with a high-conflict personality spouse. Here is a continuation of the tips. It is best that you read the first […]