U.S. Capital

In Wake of Sagging Oil Prices, Petroleum Baron Files Appeal in Divorce Case

Jan 23, 2015

Fairfax, VA (Law Firm Newswire) January 23, 2015 – Multi-billionaire Harold Hamm is making the case that passive factors led to the acquisition of wealth during his former marriage — and that his ex-wife is therefore entitled to less of the oil fortune than originally determined.

In November, one of the largest divorce cases in U.S. history seemingly concluded when an Oklahoma court ordered oil kingpin Harold Hamm to pay his ex-wife nearly $1 billion. At the time, Hamm, who was estimated to have a personal fortune of $19 billion, called the ruling “fair and equitable” and declared himself happy to have the case behind him. 

Hamm, however, has changed his mind and filed an appeal, now calling the divorce ruling “erroneous and inequitable.”

Hamm’s legal about-face comes on the heels of sharply falling oil prices that have reduced his personal fortune to half its former size. And the multi-billionaire has made the tumbling price of crude oil the center of his rationale for filing the appeal, arguing that his 68 percent stake in Continental Resources, which he owned prior to his 26-year marriage to Sue Ann Arnall, skyrocketed in value during the marriage as a result of “passive” or market factors.

“Making a vast fortune drilling for oil may or may not involve passive factors such as chance,” commented Lisa McDevitt, a prominent Fairfax, Virginia, attorney who specializes in family law. “The most successful oilman in the United States — Continental is the top driller in North Dakota’s petroleum boom — is essentially making the case that striking it rich in the Bakken oil fields was due to sheer luck.”

Proving the point that Hamm’s stake in Continental has risen and fallen in value due to passive or market factors will be pivotal in his appeal. According to Oklahoma law, only marital wealth that is accumulated as a result of active efforts or skills of either spouse can be divided in a divorce.

Hamm’s December 16 appeal actually follows one that Arnall has already filed, which asserts that the divorce ruling wrongly allowed Hamm to retain more than 90 percent of the wealth the couple amassed together. Arnall, who was an attorney for Continental in the 1980s and 1990s, claims that she was involved in a series of successful lawsuits against competitors that resulted in millions of dollars in profits, which were subsequently reinvested in drilling for oil.

Both appeals will be heard by the Oklahoma Supreme Court.

“Hamm’s request to consider post-divorce evidence involving market price swings is rather unorthodox,” McDevitt said. “But with ultra-high stakes involved, this is far from your garden-variety divorce case, and there is an incentive to find creative legal strategies.”

Learn more at http://www.mcdevittlaw.net

Lisa Lane McDevitt
2155 Bonaventure Drive
Vienna, VA 22181
Phone: 571-223-7642
Toll Free: 866-602-7850

  • When filing for a divorce, finding fault is not always necessary
    If there was ever an appropriate circumstance, divorce proceedings would seem a prime candidate for an exercise in finger-pointing. However, legally speaking, there are situations in which spouses parting ways should seek what is known as a no-fault divorce. Traditionally, some sort of misconduct has formed the grounds for a divorce. But modern divorce laws […]
  • As circumstances change, ‘Last Will and Testament’ may not be final word on an estate
    “Last Will and Testament” is a popular title for the document in which a person, known as a testator, names one or more people to manage his or her estate and provides for the distribution of his or her property after death. But when a person’s life circumstances change, a “Last Will and Testament” may […]
  • When a couple divorces, debts as well as property must be equitably divided
    Marriage can be likened to a business contract, and when that contract is dissolved during a divorce the division of assets is an important and often contentious matter. But debts are an equally important matter to resolve when any contract, including marriage, terminates, as any debts a couple holds will also be allocated between the […]
  • IRS offers holiday season tidings on tax exclusions estate planners should remember
    The holiday season upon us, meaning that the remainder of the year will see a significant amount of purchasing and bestowing gifts. The spirit of giving is not lost upon the federal government, particularly regarding those gifts with significant valuations, or those bequeathed by an estate. Accordingly, the Internal Revenue Service has announced its gift […]
  • Parental communication helps pave the way for a reasonable visitation schedule
    When couples with irreconcilable differences end their marriage through a divorce, the bonds between the spouses are effectively severed. Each party can proceed with his or her life separately. However, if a soon-to-be-splitting couple has children, some level of communication between the parents will necessarily linger, particularly once child custody has been determined and reasonable […]
  • When spouses wish to part ways, the finality of divorce is usually best
    As a popular culture would have us believe, breaking up is hard to do. With all the emotional and financial upheaval that is often involved with a nuptial parting of the ways, some on-the-rocks couples opt for what may seem to be the easier route of some form of separation.  Despite the first-blush attractiveness of […]