U.S. Capital

James Law Group Analyzes Recent Wrongful Death Dismissal Over Missouri One Recovery Rule

Sep 19, 2014

St. Peters, MO, (Law Firm Newswire) September 19, 2014 – The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has affirmed the dismissal of a Missouri family’s wrongful death claim on the grounds of Missouri’s “one recovery rule.”

Michael Thompson had been smoking for decades when he was diagnosed with lung cancer in 1997. After his diagnosis, Thompson pursued and won a personal injury claim against several tobacco companies. 

Then, in 2009, Thompson died of cancer, and his family brought a wrongful death lawsuit against a group of tobacco companies. But because Thompson had previously recovered compensation for harm caused by cigarette smoking, the federal district court dismissed the wrongful death case.

“In Missouri, a very old rule called the “one recovery rule” prevents plaintiffs from being compensated twice for the same harm,” explained Charlie James, a Missouri attorney who represents personal injury and wrongful death claims.

“This rule can put families in a difficult position. If a harm done today — like cigarette smoking, or a car accident — has caused an injury now, but is likely to result in even more hardship years into the future, when should the victim file suit?” James continued. “Competent personal injury attorneys in Missouri must take this rule into consideration when evaluating a case.”

Missouri’s one recovery rule was created in 1906, when the Missouri Supreme Court ruled that a family did not have a separate cause of action to recover damages for wrongful death after a streetcar accident killed the family’s father. In the Thompson case, the plaintiffs argued that law regarding wrongful death had evolved since 1906.

The federal district court and the Eighth Circuit disagreed, however, pointing to the original language of the 1906 rule, which states that for one wrongful act, only one recovery is possible.

On record, the case is Thompson v. Reynolds Tobacco Company Mfg USA, number 13-3005, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.

Learn more at http://www.jameslawgroup.net/.

James Law Group, LLC
14 Richmond Center Court
St. Peters, MO 63376

Phone: 636.397.2411
Toll Free: 800.229.7112



  • New report calls on employers to help prevent MSDs
    The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) has released a new report designed to help employers prevent the development of musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) in their employees. The report focuses on the ways employers can assess and correct the injury risks posed by work postures and repetitive motions. Some of the most common and […]
  • Identifying signs of unintentional nursing home neglect
    Nursing home neglect is not always intentional. It is easy to imagine those who would mistreat elders as malicious or unbalanced. But kind, considerate caregivers who lack training can endanger patients through inadvertent neglect. A cheerful and pleasant caregiver does not always guarantee the safety of a long-term care resident in his or her charge. […]
  • Causation standard for Missouri workers’ comp retaliation claims lowered
    A new decision from the Missouri Supreme Court will make it easier for employees to succeed in a claim of workers’ compensation retaliation. According to the ruling, an employee need only show that the filing of the claim was a contributory factor in a dismissal or unfavorable job action. Previously, claimants in Missouri needed to […]
  • State Settles with Insurance Firms over Workers’ Compensation Irregularities
    An insurance business truism: insurance companies love to collect money, but they detest parting with it. And a prominent January settlement between the Missouri Department of Insurance and two insurance companies certainly backed up the truth behind the stereotype. State insurance regulators settled with EMCASCO Insurance Company and Employers Mutual Casualty Company after examiners found […]
  • Missouri Marijuana Legalization Could Save Millions and Reduce Incarceration State-Wide
    Mere talk of medical marijuana legalization has some Missouri lawmakers scurrying; the state government is now preemptively passing resolutions to record the position of opposing local governments. While medical or recreational legalization of the drug in the Show Me State may remain unlikely for the present moment, it is far more certain that legalized marijuana […]