NFL Brain Injury Settlement Raises Other Issues Says Cleveland Brain Injury Lawyer Christopher Mellino

Cleveland, OH (Law Firm Newswire) November 6, 2013 — For years the NFL has denied any links between concussions on the football field and traumatic brain injury (TBI). Recently, they settled out of court for $765 million over concussion-related TBI.

Mellino Robenalt LLC has Cleveland Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury Attorneys

Mellino Robenalt LLC has Cleveland Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury Attorneys

While the settlement is regarded as proof that concussions are the precursor to TBI, it was also offered without any admission of liability or weakness claims. Witnesses never had a chance to tell their stories and allegedly exculpatory documents were not aired in court. Settling out of court means not facing the process of discovery and deposition. This settlement leaves many pointed questions begging for answers.

The settlement includes $4 million for deceased players, diagnosed after death with chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), $5 million for athletes with Alzheimer’s and $3 million for players with dementia. There is also a clause that commits the League to spend $10 million on concussion care. “Considering the League makes, on average, $9.5 billion a year, it could be said that they got off the hook easily by settling out of court. That is often done if the defendant is not confident in their case,” explained Christopher Mellino, a Cleveland traumatic brain injury lawyer with Mellino Robenalt, LLC. “Had this case gone to trial, the possibilities of a much higher jury award existed.”

Since the 4,500 cases are mainly predicated on the allegation that the League deliberately withheld information from their players about concussions leading to CTE, Alzheimer’s and dementia, the question becomes how dangerous is playing football and how serious are blows to the head? Without a look at the NFL documents that will not see the light of day, yet, no one knows for certain what the League knew about TBI and how long they have known it was a potentially serious issue.
The settlement does have an opt-out option, and it is likely a number of players will appeal and raise numerous objections to the settlement. “That could make the next step in litigation rather interesting,” added Mellino, “as on appeal, there may be a chance to submit the League documents into evidence.”

Why is it important for concussions sustained by athletes to be taken seriously? “They need to be taken seriously because concussions open the door to TBI and other brain disorders. It is only thanks to the brain injury lawyers who have been handling the mass tort cases for injured players, negligently put back into playing a game after a concussion, that a settlement was negotiated. It will be thanks to the same brain injury lawyers that those who wish to appeal will be able to move forward seeking justice,” Mellino said.

Learn more at

Mellino Robenalt LLC
75 Public Square #1020
Cleveland, OH 44113

19704 Center Ridge Rd.
Rocky River, OH 44116
Call: 440.333.3800

  • Birth Asphyxia and Brain Damage: How a Lack of Oxygen to the Brain Can Lead to Injury
    Birth asphyxia (a lack of oxygen to the brain prior to or during birth) can lead to serious brain damage. Oxygen deprivation can occur during birth for many reasons. As such, it is crucial that medical personnel identify and address the situation in as swift and capable a manner as possible. Correct diagnosis and treatment may, in some cases, lessen the negative effects of a lack of oxygen to the brain. Those who suspect that medical negligence could be responsible for the severe brain trauma during birth or birth asphyxiation may consult a Cleveland birth injury attorney. What is birth asphyxia […]
  • What Do Traumatic Brain Injuries and Yams Have in Common?
    It’s all about progesterone. If Rhode Island researchers are right, and can prove what they are seeing on a larger scale, there may be even more hope for someone with a brain injury. The ProTECT study is being carried on in a small room in the Rhode Island Hospital, led by an E.R. doctor. The “Pro” part stands for progesterone, which, according to the American Fertility Association, “is a hormone that is released by the ovaries and is important for menstrual function and pregnancy.” The rationale behind this exercise is that progesterone exists, naturally, in women and men. The difference […]
  • Contact sports are exciting; TBIs not so much
    Sports are entertaining, however, with increasing emphasis on winning at all costs, including the encouragement of violence on and off the playing field, traumatic brain injury is becoming more frequent.  According to the Centers for Disease Control, approximately 4 million sports-related concussions are reported every year. That figure does not include boxing, workplace accidents, slip and fall accidents, or car accidents. Concussions are the result of the brain smashing into the skull, causing brain tissues to swell and nerves to be injured. Head trauma may lead to a variety of symptoms, such as ringing in the ears, balance issues, nausea, fatigue, […]